Draft op-ed: Coloradans deserve to know what our care dollars are buying

November 20, 2026. A draft by Andrew Rose, not yet published elsewhere.

Say your babysitter is unavailable and the new corporate child entertainment service wants $500 for a special event for your kids. You are assured the children will have a good time. You pay, and the day comes and goes, so you ask what the money bought. You get no answer.

That's essentially how Colorado spends $1.5 billion on Medicaid mental health care. Taxpayers foot the bill, but can't see what that money buys. Coloradans deserve transparency, particularly for the precious health care dollars that provide for our low-income neighbors.

There is much concern about growth in Medicaid spending. On November 12 outgoing Governor Polis called out Wall Street for 'cleverly' driving that growth, stating, "much of the behavior from private equity firms that are overbilling is still legal… much of it might be called clever, or manipulative, but not outright illegal."

So who are the Medicaid mental health managers? There are only three. Anthem, rebranded as Elevance, manages spending for Boulder, Golden, and Colorado Springs. Non-profit Colorado Access manages Denver and Aurora. United Healthcare, which converted the non-profit Rocky Mountain Health Plans into for-profit in 2016, manages the rest of the state.

While not private equity, Anthem and United Healthcare behave similarly as they engage beyond state lines in financialized, acquisition-driven, vertically integrated corporate practices, for the benefit of investors and executives.

Are they clever? The regulating statistic for Medicaid spending under Colorado's managed care system is called the "MLR" or medical loss ratio. While federally defined, and somewhat complex, it basically shows care spending divided by the amount given to the manager. This is required to exceed 85% by federal law. Now that the Joint Budget Committee has the arduous task of cutting Medicaid spending growth, knowing how the $1.5 billion given to the managers is spent seems important. But the data is not available.

Up until 2024, medical loss ratio reports were published on the Colorado's Health Care Financing and Policy (HCPF) website. Now the old reports are gone, and there are no new reports. The legislature has partially addressed this in HB25-1213, which requires publication. The absence of these statistics, so important for public oversight of this enormous and expensive program, violates the 2025 law, enables cleverness, and blocks accountability. Older reports are hosted by COMBINE at combinebh.org/MLR-data.

Could hiding these statistics help Colorado? Managers could argue that the data is proprietary, and that disclosure could impact competitiveness. But why should providing mental health care for Colorado's poorest be competitive? What is in these statistics that is so important to hide?

Perhaps publishing this data would put some Coloradans protected health information at risk, as HCPF has argued. These reports are aggregates of spending in categories and other financial data. There is no identity or health information in these statistics.

Are the managers' behaviors, as Governor Polis put it, clever or manipulative, but not outright illegal?

Since there is no public data available for FY24-25, and FY25-26, there is no telling. The Joint Budget Committee staff could analyze the data, in about an hour using modern analytical tools, and the JBC could be more informed about the expense of paying for-profit managers and what exactly Colorado is getting for the money.

Our analysis of older data reveals some clever, sophisticated patterns. Sometimes the managers need to return unspent funds. Data shows that payers took these amounts out of the denominator, increasing their MLR and obscuring the underspending on care. Payers sometimes report office work as "quality." Federal rules prohibit counting audit and care denial expenses as "care", and yet there is evidence that it happens.

Anthem and United Healthcare's Colorado operations report and push profits up to sophisticated Wall Street organizations. Those amounts are worth knowing, and are reported as 0$ in several reports. There are additional irregularities, such as missing officer signatures, missing quality metrics, and missing descriptions of 'quality' work.

So you could ask your kids about their experience with the corporate child entertainment service, and they may say "meh" or "it was cool" but they couldn't know the spending details. This is the current level of oversight of Medicaid mental health care because data is simply not available.

Colorado is correct to be wary, given the profit demands of Wall Street and the track record of these organizations. Otherwise, as Governor Polis stated, when referring to the precious and fragile Medicaid mental health system, "it's our fault for leaving it so wide open it could be abused."

Andrew Rose has directed Boulder Emotional Wellness, a Medicaid mental health clinic with 65 staff clinicians, serving Colorado statewide, since 2008. Andrew also organizes outpatient Medicaid clinics with COMBINE, a state level advocacy group.

The governor's quotes are from his November 12, 2026 appearance before the Joint Budget Committee. Watch the hearing (Colorado General Assembly video archive).

Last reviewed 2026-11-22