History
COMBINE began in November 2019, when providers organized against a 20% cut to Medicaid outpatient mental health rates. Since then we have drafted bills, filed public comments and pressed state agencies and payers for accountability. This page lists that work, newest first, with links to the documents.
Acronyms used here: Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF), Colorado's Medicaid agency; Regional Accountable Entity (RAE), the managed care entities that run Medicaid behavioral health; Behavioral Health Administration (BHA); Division of Insurance (DOI); Joint Budget Committee (JBC); Legislative Audit Committee (LAC); Office of the State Auditor (OSA); Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA); Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA); independent provider network (IPN).
Open concerns (as of 2024)
These issues were still open when the old timeline was last updated. The year shows when COMBINE first raised each one.
| Concern | COMBINE's ask | Since |
|---|---|---|
| Parity enforcement | A Colorado body that can hear, substantiate and act on MHPAEA parity violations | 2019 |
| Rate-setting parity | Set behavioral health rates the way medical rates are set | 2019 |
| Network adequacy reporting | Count supervised candidates and interns, for example with a modifier code or individual NPIs | 2020 |
| Legislative oversight | Real scrutiny of agency statistics at annual SMART Act hearings (background report, PDF) | 2020 |
| Audit of managed care entities | Public data on RAE network capacity and care coordination results | 2020 |
| RAE contracting times | Contracting within the 90 days HCPF's RAE contracts require | 2021 |
| eConsult | Include mental health care in HCPF's eConsult platform | 2022 |
| Behavioral Health Entity (BHE) licensing | Waivers for small clinics on zoning, building codes and supervision ratios | 2023 |
| Colorado Client Assessment Record (CCAR) | Exempt outpatient care; claims data is enough | 2023 |
| Z-codes for children | Drop the requirement; the data would not be reliable | 2023 |
| Supervised services in commercial plans | Uniform rules allowing pre-licensure work as people move from Medicaid to marketplace plans | 2023 |
| Behavioral Health Ombuds office | Staffing to match its mandate | 2023 |
| Commercial lease restrictions | Bar landlords from limiting a building to one mental health office | 2024 |
2026
- Prior authorization and SB22-156 (January–November). Members prepared testimony for the Joint Budget Committee's January hearing with HCPF. On August 12, COMBINE asked HCPF to remove web text saying RAEs could require prior authorization after 24 psychotherapy sessions a year. HCPF's legal division replied that the text was outdated and would be removed. In November, an HCPF budget request (R-06.I) proposed lifting SB22-156's ban on prior authorization for outpatient psychotherapy, and COMBINE asked members to contact legislators. Read about prior authorization.
- Artificial intelligence in psychotherapy (February–June). COMBINE drafted HB26-1139, Use of Artificial Intelligence in Health Care, with Representative Junie Joseph, and asked members to testify in March, April and May. The governor signed HB26-1139 on June 2; it takes effect January 1, 2027. HB26-1195, Psychotherapy Artificial Intelligence Restrictions, was signed June 3 and took effect August 12. Read about AI in health care.
- H.R. 1 work requirements (February–November). COMBINE reviewed HCPF's draft work requirements eligibility form in February. In July it asked members to comment to the federal government before the July 31 deadline. COMBINE then briefed members on the medical frailty exemption, HCPF's draft self-attestation questions and the October 29 court ruling. Read about H.R. 1 work requirements.
- Commission on Medicaid (June–November). The legislature created the commission in 2026 to find a sustainable Medicaid budget. COMBINE asked members to co-sign a July letter to it, members gave public comment in August, and COMBINE asked for recommendations by October 19. See the news coverage.
- Provider participation, HB26-1002 (January–April). COMBINE tracked HB26-1002, Provider Participation in Health Insurance and pressed for stronger contracting language. It was signed April 27 and takes effect August 12.
- Behavioral Health Entity (BHE) licensing rules (January–October). COMBINE alerted members to the BHA's new proposed BHE rules in January and invited them to a draft-rules meeting in Boulder on March 11. In October it flagged the return of a provision limiting interns to 25% of staff.
- Payer audits and clawbacks (February–September). COMBINE warned members about large audits by CCHA, Anthem's Medicaid plan for RAEs 6 and 7, and a major clawback by Optum. In August it asked members to file complaints about CCHA clawbacks reaching back more than a year. COMBINE also arranged a September 10 meeting with Colorado Access and its audit contractor.
- RAE oversight and transparency (June–November). COMBINE circulated one-pagers on bills about a Medicaid payment floor and medical loss ratio (MLR) reporting. In August it drafted a secret-shopper demand letter to HCPF on provider access. In November a request for state fiscal year 2024-25 MLR data was denied under the Colorado Open Records Act, and COMBINE wrote a draft op-ed on the missing reports. See the MLR data. On November 20, COMBINE finished a review of HCPF's policy memos against the Administrative Procedure Act. Read about HCPF procedure.
- The 2026 session (January–May). COMBINE reviewed dozens of new bills, voted on positions and organized testimony. In February it launched a tool that helps members write to their own state legislators.
- Building the organization (March–July). The board created a Substance Use Disorder (SUD) Committee in April and took up hiring a law firm. In July it signed a new advocacy and policy support contract. Meet the board.
2025
- Safety-net status and Anthem (January–February). Anthem, which manages CCHA for RAEs 6 and 7, refused some clinics' requests to join its safety-net network. COMBINE held a directors' meeting on January 3 and an emergency meeting on January 17 after BHA did not respond. On January 28, COMBINE objected in writing to Anthem and CCHA staff. On February 1 it wrote to five legislators, asking them to question Anthem and to consider legislation making network adequacy decisions public.
- End of the state minimum rate (April–July). HCPF announced it would stop setting directed payments for outpatient behavioral health on July 1, 2025, ending the state-set minimum rate. On April 30, COMBINE sent legislators an alarm about the lost rate and the requirement to re-contract with RAEs. In May it asked members to email legislators because outpatient care had been written out of SB25-290, which created stabilization payments for safety-net providers. The governor signed SB25-290 on May 28.
- Payer audits, clawbacks and fee cuts (March–October). On March 12, COMBINE's data chair filed a complaint with the Division of Insurance about Anthem's growing medical-records requests to clinics. The complaint called them an administrative burden and a possible parity problem. COMBINE also circulated guidance on audits and time limits for clawbacks, and complaint links after fee reductions by CCHA and Aetna.
- Federal Medicaid cuts (January–October). COMBINE tracked the federal budget bill that became H.R. 1. It circulated scripts for calling Colorado's congressional delegation in February and asked members to call again in May. By September it was following Colorado's work requirements planning and had analyzed H.R. 1's work requirement and cost-sharing provisions.
- The 2025 session (January–May). COMBINE asked clinicians and directors to testify by Zoom in January and prepared a one-pager on HB25-1124, on contract protections. It analyzed HB25-1174, which would have set outpatient behavioral health reimbursement at no less than 135% of the Medicare rate in some plans. That bill died.
- Prior authorization and SB22-156 (February–December). In February COMBINE asked members to write the Joint Budget Committee after the governor's budget office proposed reinstating prior authorization for outpatient psychotherapy. In October it circulated a draft letter to the Attorney General, arguing that HCPF and the RAEs were undermining SB22-156. In December, at a Joint Budget Committee staff briefing, legislators questioned HCPF's request to repeal the law. Read about prior authorization.
- Artificial intelligence in psychotherapy (March–November). On July 27, COMBINE wrote to state officials about a product marketed as an AI therapist. It asked for a cease-and-desist order, a bar on insurance payment for AI sessions billed as psychotherapy, and a labeling law. COMBINE spent the fall reviewing a bill on AI psychotherapy, which became HB26-1139. Read about AI in health care.
- Supervision, licensure and workforce (March–August). COMBINE followed the licensing board's rulemaking and the path to licensure for counselors with non-conforming degrees. In August it held supervision meetings and circulated HCPF's comment form on its supervision policy.
- Building the organization (July–December). A new board formed on August 8, and the board contracted a lobbyist with Joint Budget Committee experience. COMBINE invited members to a new Policy Committee in August and circulated one-page policy documents for review in September. Meet the board.
2024
- February 24, 2024. COMBINE filed parity comments in response to HCPF's annual call. Read the February 2024 parity comments to HCPF (PDF).
- February 1, 2024. COMBINE took an amend position on SB24-093, continuity of care. The bill protects care when a person moves from Medicaid to other insurance, but the draft left out mental health care.
2023
- December 1, 2023. COMBINE asked HCPF for an open meetings policy. Public online meetings had stopped showing participants. At one HCPF stakeholder meeting on Z-codes for children, participants and the Q&A were hidden.
- November 28, 2023. COMBINE asked Child Health Plan Plus (CHP+) managers to clarify supervised billing.
- November 8, 2023. Member clinic directors filed complaints with the DOI. They asked it to make UnitedHealthcare (RAE 1 and commercial plans) follow the DOI directive allowing supervised billing (PDF).
- November 3, 2023. COMBINE asked members to urge legislators to fund 10 staff positions for the Behavioral Health Ombuds office. Read the action letter to legislators (Google Doc).
- October 20, 2023. HCPF released its report required by HB23-1269. In it, HCPF acknowledges it has the power to require minimum rates from the RAEs. Read HCPF's HB23-1269 directed payment report (PDF).
- October 20, 2023. HCPF proposed requiring Z-codes on claims for children under 21, to gather social determinants of health data. COMBINE's view is that this runs contrary to the law. Read HCPF's proposed policy and the signed SB23-174 (PDF).
- October 19, 2023. COMBINE again objected that HCPF's eConsult platform leaves out mental health care. eConsult lets primary care doctors and specialists share protected health information. COMBINE first raised this as a parity concern in 2022; in May 2022, HCPF's eConsult team confirmed by email that behavioral health would not be included.
- October 12, 2023. Dozens of clinic operators signed COMBINE's letter asking the LAC to audit the RAEs. The OSA would need added authority to audit them. Read the 2023 letter requesting a RAE audit (PDF).
- October 11, 2023. COMBINE asked the BHA to exempt non-substance-use outpatient care from CCAR reporting. Read the CCAR comment to the BHA (PDF).
- August 30, 2023. COMBINE asked for workable BHE licensing rules for small clinics. Asks included waivers from the fire-safety certificate of compliance and changes to training, medical assessment and referral requirements. Read the August 2023 comment on BHE licensing (PDF).
- August 1, 2023. HCPF's HB22-1268 action plan acknowledged its power to set minimum rates, already used for some services. COMBINE disputes its framing that Medicaid rates should be compared with commercial rates. Read HCPF's HB22-1268 action plan (PDF).
- June 6, 2023. The DOI issued a directive supporting supervised services in commercial plans, after COMBINE raised the issue. Read DOI directive B-4.131 (PDF).
- February 28, 2023. COMBINE joined other providers in commenting on proposed BHA licensing rules. As drafted, the rules would have closed nearly all small clinics with internship programs. Read the 2023 BHA rules comment (PDF).
2022
- December 9, 2022. Colorado Access (RAEs 3 and 5) switched direct deposit vendors and charged a 2% fee. It later offered a no-fee option.
- December 4, 2022. Colorado Community Health Alliance (CCHA; Anthem and Carelon, RAEs 6 and 7) failed to pay claims for weeks.
- September 30, 2022. The RAEs agreed to DORA's supervision standards for interns and externs, a COMBINE win.
- September 29, 2022. The LAC dropped a proposal to give the OSA authority to audit the RAEs. Representative Michaelson Jenet suggested waiting to see what the BHA would do.
- September 23, 2022. COMBINE warned legislators that proposed RAE supervision changes would cut supervision for early-career counselors. Read the memo to legislators on RAE supervised practice policy (PDF).
- September 10, 2022. A clinical supervisor described why early-career therapists need supervision in diverse workplaces. Read the statement on RAE supervision policy (PDF).
- September 9, 2022. A U.S. Army veteran and clinic owner wrote legislators that the supervision policy could shut down small practices. Read the veteran clinic owner's letter (PDF).
- September 5, 2022. COMBINE responded to the HB22-1268 rate report. We found it did not meet the law's intent, ignored workforce effects and skipped MHPAEA parity. Read COMBINE's response to the HB22-1268 report (PDF) or the Google Doc version.
- August 2022. Anthem's prior authorization requirement for outpatient behavioral health ended, with SB22-156.
- August 20, 2022. The HB22-1268 provider rate comparison report came out. It was meant to explain why independent providers are paid one fifth of what community mental health centers get for the same 55-minute session. Optumas and Myers and Stauffer prepared it. Read the HB22-1268 report (PDF).
- July 20, 2022. COMBINE responded to HCPF's 2022 parity report (PDF). The report denied that the RAE structure itself violates parity and ignored differences in rate setting. Read COMBINE's response to the 2022 parity report (PDF).
- July 7, 2022. COMBINE formed its 501(c)(4), raised dues and reported more than 150 members. Yakitta Renfroe was Board Chair. Board members were Carlos Villafan, Faith Halverson Ramos, Lexi Ellis and Andy Rose.
- July 2022. Automatic denials of F64 (gender dysphoria) codes were rescinded. COMBINE also updated its 2022 policy asks, striking resolved items. Read COMBINE's 2022 policy asks (PDF).
- 2022. COMBINE helped draft two bills. HB22-1268, the bipartisan Medicaid rate report, was introduced by Representatives Amabile and Holtorf. SB22-156, on prior authorization and recoupment, was sponsored by Senate President Fenberg, Senator Kolker, Representative Amabile and Representative Young. SB22-156 protects providers from recoupment of paid claims and prohibits prior authorization for outpatient care.
- 2022. COMBINE clarified with the Office of Behavioral Health, the Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment, HCPF, the BHA and the RAEs which clinics need BHE licenses.
- March 2022. Colorado Access and COMBINE began a pilot allowing supervised pre-licensure care. Colorado Access had barred the practice for two years, unlike the other RAEs. Colorado Access now allows supervised billing.
- February 2022. COMBINE prepared remarks for the Senate Health Committee on a commercial prior authorization bill, asking that it cover Medicaid. SB22-156 later settled the issue for Medicaid outpatient mental health care. Read the February 2022 remarks on prior authorization (PDF).
- February 2022. COMBINE topped 100 member clinics.
- February 2022. Members met with Gainwell, HCPF's vendor, about validation timelines. Gainwell promised a five-day turnaround. As of December 2023, providers still struggled with its call center, especially for revalidation.
- January 20, 2022. Ten COMBINE members testified before the JBC.
- January 2022. After COMBINE advocacy, licensed professional counselors (LPCs) were approved to treat patients enrolled in both Medicaid and Medicare. LPCs could not then bill Medicare.
- January 2022. COMBINE shared a third-party report on the national behavioral health workforce crisis, from Health Management Associates and the National Council for Mental Wellbeing. Read "Behavioral Health Workforce is a National Crisis" (PDF).
2022 projects
COMBINE tracked these projects in 2022. Outcomes are noted where the record shows them.
| Project | Outcome |
|---|---|
| HB22-1068, Medicaid reimbursement for therapy using equines | |
| Proper documentation (treatment plans, progress notes) | |
| SB22-156, prior authorization and recoupment | Passed; Anthem's prior authorization ended August 2022 |
| HB22-1268, rate audit | Report published August 20, 2022; COMBINE responded September 5, 2022 |
| Expand the benefit to preventive care | |
| Minimum rates and parity in rate setting | Still open (see open concerns) |
| Commercial payers to support pre-licensure work | DOI directive B-4.131, June 6, 2023 |
| Increase couple and family rates | |
| End the RAE system for statewide fee-for-service | |
| Legislative Audit Committee bill | LAC dropped RAE audit authority, September 29, 2022 |
2021
- December 15, 2021. COMBINE wrote the JBC about HCPF's provider count statistics. Neither HCPF nor the RAEs tracked how much care pre-licensure clinicians delivered. Read the December 2021 letter to the JBC (PDF).
- November 18, 2021. A member clinic owner wrote legislators about RAE problems and workforce goals. Topics included credentialing, attribution, prior authorization, testing, parity, rates and no-show fees. Read the November 2021 letter of concern (PDF).
- April 1, 2021. COMBINE submitted parity concerns for HCPF's parity report. Topics included RAE contracts, reimbursement, prior authorization, pre-licensure restrictions, network adequacy, credentialing and enforcement. Read COMBINE's 2021 parity concerns (PDF).
- March 31, 2021. Clinic directors answered HCPF's request for information on how the RAEs operate. Read the HCPF rate review questions and answers (PDF).
- March 6, 2021. COMBINE and clinic directors asked Colorado Access to cover pre-licensure services, as other RAEs did. Read the March 2021 letter to Colorado Access (PDF).
- March 5, 2021. DORA's Board of LPC Examiners approved Naropa University's equivalency with Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs (CACREP) standards for the class of 2021. Third-year students could then apply for their LPC candidate license before graduating.
- March 2021. Anthem (RAEs 6 and 7) required prior authorization for routine outpatient care, which COMBINE considers a parity violation. COMBINE helped clinicians comply and collected evidence that most requests were approved. The requirement ended in August 2022, with SB22-156. Read the March 2021 prior authorization letter to clients (PDF).
- March 1, 2021. SB21-126 would have limited contracting time to 60 days, but left out mental health workers. COMBINE wrote the sponsors. Read the SB21-126 contracting time letter (PDF).
- February 28, 2021. COMBINE commented on DOI parity regulation 4-2-64. Topics included screenings, court-ordered services, prior authorization, extension codes and supervised work. Read the DOI regulation 4-2-64 parity comment (PDF).
- February 21, 2021. COMBINE sent the JBC oversight questions for its HCPF hearing. Topics were network adequacy, reimbursement, parity, prior authorization and credentialing. Read the February 2021 oversight questions (PDF).
- February 15, 2021. COMBINE reviewed the RAEs' quarterly network adequacy reports to HCPF. We found delayed and missing data, inconsistent provider counts, no data on pre-licensure services and heavy redactions. Read COMBINE's February 2021 network adequacy review (PDF).
- January 16, 2021. COMBINE started its Facebook group and an action email list, with 9 subscribers and 8 dues-paying voting members. It also pressed Colorado Access to allow pre-licensure work outside licensed facilities.
2020
- December 29, 2020. COMBINE formed a Small Donor Political Committee to contribute to political campaigns.
- 2020. COMBINE began helping develop the Medicaid RAE Escalation form (Google Form).
- January 5, 2020. Boulder Beat published COMBINE's letter to the editor on protecting the mental health safety net. Read the letter (PDF).
2019
- November 19, 2019. COMBINE and the Colorado Counseling Association asked Boulder City Council for its lobbyists' help protecting Medicaid mental health care after the 20% cut. Read the contemporaneous tweets from the meeting (PDF).
- November 2019. COMBINE first organized to fight a 20% cut to outpatient Medicaid mental health rates. Anthem (RAEs 6 and 7) had paid the Medicaid Provider Rate Review Advisory Committee (MPRRAC) rate in 2018 and 2019, then called it a mistake. Andrew Rose sought help from an attorney on the Wit v. United Behavioral Health parity case, and met with Anthem without result. He also met with HCPF and Representative Singer, chair of the House Public & Behavioral Health & Human Services Committee. HCPF's position was that rates were up to the RAEs. Read the November 2019 appeal, meeting notes and agenda (PDF).
Other results (dates to confirm)
- Rocky Mountain Health Plans cancelled its preauthorization requirements.
- CCHA shortened its clawback period to one year from payment.
- HCPF put recoupment limits of 365 days into RAE contracts.
- HCPF and RAEs 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 began meeting regularly with COMBINE teams.
- Members gave input on HCPF's rendering provider oversight rules, the HCPF supervision policy for Medicaid billable behavioral health services (PDF).
- COMBINE increased press coverage of mental health in Colorado.
Last reviewed 2026-11-22