HCPF procedure

The Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) changes what Medicaid covers and pays by sending policy memos to the managed care entities. COMBINE's review found that many of these memos bind providers and members statewide. They were never adopted through the rulemaking process Colorado's Administrative Procedure Act (APA) requires.

The problem

HCPF contracts with Regional Accountable Entities (RAEs) and managed care organizations (MCOs). It instructs them through policy transmittals and operational memos. Providers and members are not the addressees, yet they bear the effect: claim denials, prior authorization, unit caps and recoupment.

The APA sets the path for a binding agency rule: outreach, notice in the Colorado Register, a hearing, legal review and a delayed effective date. For Medicaid benefits and provider payment rules, the General Assembly assigned that work to the Medical Services Board, not to HCPF staff.

COMBINE reviewed 34 memos issued from July 2025 through August 2026. Almost every memo that crosses the line shares the same traits:

  • It was sent only to the RAEs.
  • A division director signed it, not the Medical Services Board.
  • It never appeared in the Colorado Register.
  • It took effect in days or weeks. Four took effect retroactively.

Several memos say they stand in for a billing manual or contract amendment that does not exist yet.

Key facts

  • Of the 34 memos reviewed, 17 appear to be rules adopted without APA procedures. Two more technically qualify but make poor test cases. Fifteen are contract administration the APA does not reach. Source: COMBINE, HCPF Governance by Memo (November 20, 2026, PDF).
  • Colorado's APA defines a rule as any agency statement of general applicability and future effect that implements law or policy. Colorado has no exemption for contracts or benefits like the federal APA's. Source: C.R.S. § 24-4-102.
  • An agency may not rely on or cite against anyone a rule that was not published and made available. That is what makes denials and recoupments based on these memos open to challenge. Source: C.R.S. § 24-4-103.
  • State law directs the Medical Services Board to adopt rules on benefits, eligibility and provider rights and payment, and to put utilization management guidelines for managed care into its rules. Sources: C.R.S. § 25.5-1-303 and C.R.S. § 25.5-5-402.

Examples COMBINE flagged

  • Psychotherapy prior authorization (October–November 2025). Required prior authorization after 24 sessions per year and review of sessions already delivered, with recoupment. HCPF revised it nine days later, then suspended it in April 2026 as a budget matter. The suspension did not clearly end the recoupment of 2025 sessions.
  • Supportive services provider types (June 2026). Barred two provider types from billing 36 behavioral health codes, so affected group practices must re-enroll as another provider type.
  • Unit caps and same-day billing bars (June–August 2026). Set annual and daily limits and same-day bars across many codes. HCPF withdrew the annual caps three days before they took effect.
  • Enhanced services rates and eligibility (August–October 2025). Set rates, member eligibility and billing rules for the CO-SOC enhanced services through a series of memos.
  • Assessment mandate (August 2026). Required freestanding psychiatric hospitals to complete the Adult Needs and Strengths Assessment at intake and made a missing one an administrative denial. The requirement took effect before the memo was issued.

COMBINE's position

COMBINE's concern is that binding standards for providers and members are set by memo, with no public notice, comment or Board vote. Providers cannot see policy changes coming, cannot comment on cost or clinical effect, and learn of them when claims are denied or recouped.

COMBINE asks that HCPF:

  • bring standards that bind providers and members through Medical Services Board rulemaking;
  • not deny, withhold or recoup payment on standards that were never properly adopted and published;
  • avoid retroactive effective dates.

Limits of this review

The review is advocacy analysis, not legal advice. Key limits:

  • No Colorado appellate case decides whether a binding instruction delivered through a managed care contract is a "rule." HCPF's strongest defense is that the memos are only contract instructions.
  • The executed RAE contracts were not reviewed. A clause incorporating future memos would help HCPF's defense.
  • Statute text came from unofficial online copies. Check pinpoint citations against the official statutes before filing anything.
  • Whether HCPF has already adopted any of these standards in Board rules was not checked.
  • Standing and the route for a challenge were not researched.

What we've done

  • November 20, 2026: Completed a review of 34 HCPF policy transmittals and operational memos against the APA. Read the report (PDF).

Last reviewed 2026-11-22