Rates and payment reform
Medicaid pays for medical care from a public, statewide fee schedule. Behavioral health rates are set separately by each managed care company and can change at any time. That leaves independent clinicians with lower, unpredictable pay and drives them out of Medicaid.
The problem
The Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) and the General Assembly set Medicaid provider rates. For behavioral health, though, Regional Accountable Entities (RAEs) negotiate rates under a capitated benefit. Rates differ from RAE to RAE, and provider contracts state that rates are variable and may change at any time.
Rates also differ by provider type. Community mental health centers (CMHCs) are paid cost-based rates, far above what the independent provider network (IPN) receives for the same codes. Within the IPN, master's-level clinicians are paid about 20% less than other credentials under tiered fee schedules.
State payment reform has not addressed this. A September 2022 stakeholder convening on behavioral health payment reform listed RAE compensation policies and cost-based reimbursement as out of scope.
Key facts
- HCPF adjusts rates when required by law, by the legislature's budget, or when payment components change. A separate rate review under SB15-228 examines services on a five-year cycle. Source: HCPF, Establishing Provider Payment Rates and Methodologies: A Short Primer (June 2016, PDF).
- CCHA (Anthem) cut provider reimbursement 20% starting January 1, 2020, in regions serving over 300,000 Medicaid members. Source: Letter to the editor from Medicaid clinic directors, Boulder Beat (January 5, 2020).
- Between October 2019 and October 2020, providers contracted with CCHA fell from 364 to 240. Source: Network Adequacy Report Reform 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc).
- In December 2021 the Denver Post reported that a Denver CMHC received $592 for an hour of counseling. An independent clinician received $91 for the same service. Source: COMBINE response to the HB22-1268 report (September 5, 2022, PDF), citing the Denver Post (December 5, 2021).
- HB22-1268, sponsored by Reps. Amabile and Holtorf, required HCPF to publish a behavioral health rate comparison report. HCPF published it August 15, 2022. Source: HCPF Behavioral Health Provider Rate Comparison Report (August 15, 2022, PDF).
- That report concluded independent providers' Medicaid rates will never match safety-net CMHC rates, because independent providers are not paid on a cost basis. Source: HCPF rate comparison report (August 15, 2022, PDF).
- HCPF's August 1, 2023 action plan includes comparing IPN rates with commercial insurers' rates. Source: HB22-1268 Action Plan Update (August 1, 2023, PDF).
- Under HB23-1269, HCPF set a minimum rate for certain child high-intensity outpatient services as of July 2023. It planned to expand directed payments through value-based models in July 2024. Source: HCPF HB23-1269 Directed Payment Legislative Report (October 20, 2023, PDF).
- COMBINE reports that RAE 3 and 5 (Colorado Access, Denver and Aurora) pay 30–40% more than rural RAEs. Source: COMBINE letter to the Legislative Audit Committee (October 13, 2023, PDF).
COMBINE's position
- Rate-setting parity. Behavioral health rates should be set by a process similar to medical rates: transparent and statewide. Requiring RAEs to pay at the rates set through the MPRRAC would meet that test.
- Rate floors. Legislated minimum rates would protect providers against further unilateral cuts.
- Pay for the work, not the degree. Tiered rates by credential penalize master's-level clinicians, who are most of the workforce and about 80% women.
- Payment reform must reach the RAEs. Reform that leaves RAE compensation policy out of scope cannot fix provider pay.
- Repair the 2020 cut. CCHA providers were still paid less in October 2023 than in 2018.
What we've done
- January 5, 2020: Clinic directors published a letter opposing CCHA's 20% cut. Read the letter in Boulder Beat or as a PDF.
- May 2021: Gave legislators a 1-pager on rate-setting parity and rate floors. Read the 1-pager (Google Doc).
- 2022: Supported HB22-1268, the Medicaid mental health reimbursement rates report bill. Read the HB22-1268 1-pager (March 2022, PDF on Google Drive).
- September 5, 2022: Published an analysis of HCPF's HB22-1268 rate comparison report. Read the response (PDF) or the Google Doc version.
- October 13, 2023: Raised RAE rate secrecy and regional rate gaps with the Legislative Audit Committee. Read the letter (PDF).
- February 24, 2024: Argued in parity comments that RAE rate setting is a parity issue. Read the background (PDF).
Related documents
- HCPF, Establishing Provider Payment Rates and Methodologies: A Short Primer (June 2016, PDF). Describes rate setting before the RAEs.
- Behavioral Health Payment Reform Provider Convening slides (September 9, 2022, PDF). Stakeholder meeting on Medicaid payment changes.
- HCPF Behavioral Health Provider Rate Comparison Report, HB22-1268 (August 15, 2022, PDF)
- COMBINE response to the HB22-1268 rate report (September 5, 2022, PDF)
- HCPF HB22-1268 Action Plan Update to the Joint Budget Committee (August 1, 2023, PDF)
- HCPF HB23-1269 Directed Payment Legislative Report (October 20, 2023, PDF)
- Rate Setting Parity and Rate Floors 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc)
- HB22-1268 1-pager (March 2022, PDF on Google Drive)
- Letter to the editor opposing the CCHA rate cut (January 5, 2020, PDF)
- HB22-1268 bill page
- See RAE medical loss ratio data
Last reviewed 2026-11-21