Network adequacy
Network adequacy rules decide how many providers a health plan must have, and how close they must be to members. Colorado's Medicaid behavioral health standard is far weaker than the one for commercial insurance. The state also cannot reliably say how many clinicians actually see Medicaid members.
The problem
Network adequacy covers provider counts, distance to members and related measures such as complaints. It also drives rates: when a payer must meet an enforced standard, the usual way to attract providers is to pay more.
Colorado has two sets of rules. The Division of Insurance (DOI), within the Department of Regulatory Agencies (DORA), sets standards for commercial plans under Title 10. Medicaid falls under Title 25.5, where the Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) sets standards in its contracts with Regional Accountable Entities (RAEs).
The data are weak. RAE network adequacy reports have been late, aggregated and inconsistent from year to year. Work done by supervised pre-licensure clinicians is invisible, because claims name the supervisor and not the clinician who delivered care.
Key facts
- DOI Regulation 4-2-53 (effective January 1, 2020) covers Affordable Care Act (ACA) compliant commercial plans. It requires one mental health, behavioral health or substance use disorder provider per 1,000 members. Source: Colorado Insurance Regulation 4-2-53 (PDF on Google Drive).
- Commercial carriers file network adequacy reports with DOI each July through SERFF and attest to meeting § 10-16-704, C.R.S. Source: DOI guidance quoted on the legacy COMBINE Network Adequacy page (October 7, 2022); C.R.S. § 10-16-704 (FindLaw).
- HCPF-RAE contracts (section 9.4.11) set one adult mental health practitioner per 1,800 adult members. The same 1:1,800 ratio applies to pediatric mental health and substance use disorder providers. Source: HCPF managed care contracts, as captured October 7, 2022.
- Mental Health America's 2020 figures put the best state ratio at 1:180 (Massachusetts) and the worst at 1:1,100 (Alabama). Colorado's 1:1,800 Medicaid contract ratio is weaker than the worst state. Source: Network Adequacy: Provider to Member Ratios 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc).
- HCPF received October–December 2020 RAE network data on January 31, 2021, and posted it in May 2021. Source: Network Adequacy Report Reform 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc).
- The RAE 6 report for that quarter suggested over 6,000 providers for Boulder and Golden members. The RAE's directory listed two providers accepting new child clients. Source: Network Adequacy Report Reform 1-pager (May 2021).
- CCHA (Anthem) cut counseling rates 20% in January 2020. Its contracted providers fell by a third, from 364 to 240, between October 2019 and October 2020. Source: Network Adequacy Report Reform 1-pager (May 2021); COMBINE network adequacy reports analysis (February 2021, PDF).
- In late 2021 HCPF gave two growth figures for its behavioral health network. Its newsletter said 18%; its spokesperson's numbers (6,029 to 8,371 practitioners) imply 39%. Source: COMBINE letter to the Joint Budget Committee (December 15, 2021, PDF).
- The 2020 federal Medicaid managed care rule dropped the 2016 requirement for time and distance standards, letting states use any quantitative standard. At least 70% of Medicaid beneficiaries are in managed care. Source: Zhu, Polsky, Johnstone and McConnell, "Variation in Network Adequacy Standards in Medicaid Managed Care," AJMC (June 9, 2022).
- Section 9 of the RAE contracts lists the network adequacy deliverables: quarterly reports, quarterly flat files and annual reports. Source: HCPF managed care contracts; HCPF Accountable Care Collaborative (ACC) deliverables.
Research: how states set Medicaid standards
A 2022 study in the American Journal of Managed Care (AJMC) compared network adequacy standards across state Medicaid managed care programs. The authors note that federal rules changed in 2020 to give states more freedom in choosing standards. They say it is not yet clear how that flexibility will affect which standards states pick or how plans comply.
Read the AJMC article (June 9, 2022).
COMBINE's position
- One standard. Every Colorado department should use the same definition of network adequacy. Different standards create access inequities.
- A better ratio. Colorado should improve on the 1:1,800 Medicaid ratio, which is weaker than the 1:1,000 commercial standard.
- Real reporting. Reports should be posted on a fixed timeline. They should break out providers by county, by adult and child care, and by who accepts new clients.
- Count the actual workforce. HCPF and the RAEs should count clinicians who render care under supervision.
- Consequences. Network adequacy reporting rules should carry fines for noncompliance.
What we've done
- October 10, 2020: Drafted legislative language for county-level network adequacy data and provider ratios. Read Medicaid Mental Healthcare Asks 1–7 (PDF).
- February 2021: Analyzed HCPF's posted network adequacy reports for RAEs 3, 5, 6 and 7. Read the analysis (PDF).
- February 21, 2021: Asked the Joint Budget Committee to press HCPF on accurate, timely provider rosters. Read the oversight questions (PDF).
- May 2021: Gave legislators 1-pagers on provider ratios and report reform, part of an eight-solution workforce packet. Read the May 2021 packet (PDF).
- December 15, 2021: Wrote to the Joint Budget Committee about HCPF's conflicting provider counts. Read the letter (PDF).
Related documents
- COMBINE network adequacy reports analysis, RAEs 3, 5, 6 and 7 (February 2021, PDF)
- COMBINE letter to the Joint Budget Committee on HCPF provider counts (December 15, 2021, PDF)
- Network Adequacy: Provider to Member Ratios 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc)
- Network Adequacy Report Reform 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc)
- 2022 Medicaid Behavioral Health Workforce Solutions packet for legislators (May 2021, PDF)
- 2021 Behavioral Health Task Force policy tracker, with network adequacy items (last updated January 26, 2021, Google Sheet)
- Colorado Insurance Regulation 4-2-53, network adequacy standards for ACA-compliant plans (effective January 1, 2020, PDF on Google Drive)
- AJMC, Variation in Network Adequacy Standards in Medicaid Managed Care (June 9, 2022)
- HCPF quarterly network adequacy reports and other ACC deliverables (web page)
- HCPF-RAE managed care contracts (web page)
- SERFF filing access for Colorado (web page)
- Colorado Division of Insurance (web page)
- Department of Regulatory Agencies (web page)
- HCPF (web page)
Last reviewed 2026-11-21