Mental health parity
Federal and Colorado law require Medicaid to treat mental health and substance use care on par with medical and surgical care. In practice, Colorado runs behavioral health through a separate managed care system with its own rules for rates, contracting and authorization. Providers absorb the difference, and Medicaid members lose access.
The problem
The Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act (MHPAEA) bars plans from limiting mental health and substance use care more strictly than medical care. Colorado wrote MHPAEA into its Medicaid law (Title 25.5) with HB19-1269. The Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) runs Medicaid.
HCPF pays for physical health care on a fee-for-service basis using the Medicaid fee schedule. Behavioral health is a capitated benefit managed by Regional Accountable Entities (RAEs), which negotiate their own rates with providers. COMBINE's position is that this split, by itself, creates parity violations in rate setting and contracting.
There is no working enforcement path for Medicaid parity. Commercial plan members and providers can take parity complaints to the Division of Insurance (DOI), which has a rule with fines and license sanctions. Medicaid has no equivalent: the main tool is a requirement that HCPF answer letters from the Behavioral Health Ombudsman Office of Colorado (BHOCO).
Wit v. United Behavioral Health
Wit v. United Behavioral Health (UBH) is a federal class action decided in the Northern District of California. In a March 5, 2019 ruling, Chief Magistrate Judge Joseph C. Spero found that UBH must use medical necessity guidelines that follow generally accepted standards of care. In November 2020 the court ordered UBH to reprocess nearly 67,000 denied claims using criteria from nonprofit clinical specialty associations.
The case matters for Colorado because it treats the content of utilization review criteria, not just the benefit list, as a coverage and parity question. COMBINE has highlighted Wit since at least January 2021 as a parity precedent for providers. In 2024 COMBINE noted that Colorado's Attorney General had backed the Wit parity case in another state.
Read a commentary on the Wit decision by the Medium author "psian" (web article, date not shown; COMBINE linked it March 24, 2022).
Key facts
- HB19-1269 (2019) incorporated federal MHPAEA language into Title 25.5, Colorado's Medicaid statute. Source: HB19-1269 bill page; Parity Governance 1-pager (May 2021).
- Federal parity rules for Medicaid managed care and the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) were published March 30, 2016. Source: Federal Register final rule.
- HCPF-RAE contracts (section 14.15) require MHPAEA compliance and bar non-quantitative treatment limits (NQTLs) that are stricter than those for medical care. Source: COMBINE parity comment to HCPF (March 14, 2021, PDF).
- HCPF must publish an annual parity report under C.R.S. § 25.5-5-421; the 2021–22 report came out June 1, 2022. Source: COMBINE response to the 2022 HCPF parity report (July 20, 2022, PDF).
- In a February 11, 2020 letter, HCPF said RAE rate negotiation is not a parity violation. The same letter confirmed medical services are paid from the fee schedule. Source: COMBINE parity background for HCPF comments (February 24, 2024, PDF).
- HCPF's 2022 parity report lists methods for setting usual, customary and reasonable charges as a type of NQTL. Source: COMBINE parity background (February 24, 2024, PDF).
- Commercial plans fall under DOI Regulation 3 CCR 702-4-2-64, which allows fines, cease-and-desist orders and license action. Source: Parity Governance 1-pager (May 2021).
- BHOCO was created by HB18-1357; the 2024 supplemental bill HB24-1187 restored its funding to two full-time staff. Source: COMBINE parity background (February 24, 2024, PDF).
- Federal agencies proposed a new MHPAEA rule on July 25, 2023, published it August 3, 2023, and extended comments to October 17, 2023. Source: legacy COMBINE parity page (October 2023); Mental Health Liaison Group comments (October 17, 2023, PDF).
- State attorneys general have brought parity enforcement actions in other states. Source: ParityTrack list of state enforcement actions (web page, linked November 2023).
COMBINE's position
- Independent enforcement. Colorado needs a process outside HCPF to accept, investigate and act on parity complaints against RAEs and HCPF.
- A funded ombudsman. BHOCO needs at least 10 full-time staff and access to administrative law court to substantiate violations, unless the Attorney General acts.
- Rate-setting parity. Behavioral health rates should be set the way medical rates are: transparent and statewide. Requiring RAEs to pay at the rates the MPRRAC has set would meet that test.
- Parity governance in statute. Title 25.5 should require parity compliance programs like those in New York and Massachusetts. These include a compliance officer, written policies, reporting and training.
- A private right of action so providers and members can sue over HB19-1269 violations.
What we've done
- February 21, 2021: Commented to DOI on parity Regulation 4-2-64, arguing a mental health exam is not on par with an annual physical. Read the comment (PDF).
- March 13–14, 2021: Gathered provider parity concerns and submitted them for HCPF's annual parity report. Read COMBINE's parity concerns (March 13, 2021, PDF).
- May 2021: Distributed 1-pagers to legislators on parity governance and rate-setting parity. See the 1-pagers in the library.
- July 20, 2022: Wrote to legislators and press disputing HCPF's 2022 finding that the RAE system complies with parity. Read the response (PDF).
- July 29, 2023: Analyzed the proposed federal parity rule and Colorado's options for Medicaid compliance. Read COMBINE's comments (PDF).
- November 2023: Asked legislators to fund BHOCO and create a Medicaid parity enforcement path. Read the BHOCO letter to legislators (Google Doc, last edited November 9, 2023).
- February 24, 2024: Briefed parity advocates ahead of HCPF's March 15, 2024 comment deadline. Read the background (PDF).
Related documents
- COMBINE comments on the 2023 proposed federal parity rule (July 29, 2023, PDF)
- Mental Health Liaison Group comments on the proposed MHPAEA rule, including the Kennedy Forum (October 17, 2023, PDF)
- COMBINE parity background for HCPF's 2024 comment period (February 24, 2024, PDF)
- COMBINE response to the 2022 HCPF parity report (July 20, 2022, PDF)
- COMBINE parity comment for HCPF (March 14, 2021, PDF)
- COMBINE parity concerns submitted for the HCPF parity report (March 13, 2021, PDF)
- COMBINE comment on DOI Regulation 4-2-64 (February 21, 2021, PDF)
- Parity Governance 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc)
- Rate Setting Parity and Rate Floors 1-pager (May 2021, Google Doc)
- BHOCO letter to legislators (2023, Google Doc)
- 2021 Behavioral Health Task Force policy tracker, with parity items (last updated January 26, 2021, Google Sheet)
- PsiAN insurance and parity advocacy toolkit, with a Wit overview (January 17, 2023, PDF)
- Kennedy Forum, Mental Health Milestones of 2020, including the Wit ruling (January 2021, PDF on Google Drive)
- Division of Insurance 2023 mental health parity report to the legislature (June 1, 2023, PDF)
- Division of Insurance booklet on mental and behavioral health parity rights (date not shown, PDF)
- The Kennedy Forum parity resources (web page)
- HCPF past parity reports (web page)
Last reviewed 2026-11-21