RAE accountability

Colorado Medicaid's behavioral health benefit is run by a few managed care companies under contract with the state. Their rates, payment practices and provider support shape whether clinicians can stay in Medicaid. Yet the state auditor cannot audit them directly, and providers have few ways to see or challenge what they do.

The problem

The Department of Health Care Policy and Financing (HCPF) contracts with Regional Accountable Entities (RAEs) to manage Medicaid behavioral health. The companies behind the RAEs are Anthem, United Healthcare and Colorado Access. Each RAE receives a set monthly payment per enrolled member and arranges care through its own provider contracts.

The Office of the State Auditor (OSA) can audit HCPF's oversight of the RAEs. It cannot audit the RAEs' own records without new statutory authority. The Legislative Audit Committee (LAC), which directs the OSA, has not moved a bill to grant that authority.

COMBINE is concerned about regulatory capture: managed care contractors growing so close to HCPF that providers and members lose out. RAE rate-setting policies and rates are held as trade secrets, so the public cannot compare them.

Key facts

  • HCPF contracts with six RAEs, which together served an average monthly behavioral health caseload of about 1.3 million in fiscal year 2021. Source: OSA memo to the LAC on a behavioral health audit (2022, PDF).
  • On January 11, 2022, four legislators asked the OSA to audit the behavioral health system. The LAC authorized feasibility research on January 25, 2022. Source: OSA memo to the LAC (2022, PDF).
  • The OSA memo said a direct audit of RAEs and community mental health centers would require additional statutory authority. Source: OSA memo to the LAC (2022, PDF).
  • At a September 28, 2022 LAC hearing, a motion to move the audit bill draft died for lack of a second. Source: COMBINE letter to the LAC (October 13, 2023, PDF), citing the LAC minutes (September 28, 2022, PDF).
  • The 2023–24 RAE 1 (United Healthcare) contract sets provider support standards, including a provider call queue of three minutes or less each week. Source: legacy COMBINE RAE Provider Support Standards page; HCPF managed care contracts.
  • The same contract requires answers to 95% of provider questions within two business days. It requires payment or adjudication of 95% of clean fee-for-service claims within 30 days and 99% within 60 days. Source: HCPF managed care contracts.
  • It also sets claims accuracy targets of 98% (financial) and 95% (transactional), and requires capitation payments within 48 business hours of the target date. Source: HCPF managed care contracts.
  • RAE contracts require periodic reports called deliverables. Section 9 covers network adequacy reports and Section 14 covers financial reports tied to the federal medical loss ratio (MLR). Source: HCPF managed care contracts.
  • Under the Colorado Open Records Act (CORA), C.R.S. § 24-72-202 et seq., HCPF records are public unless exempt. Exemptions include protected health information, personal information and trade secrets. Source: HCPF CORA guidance, as quoted on the legacy COMBINE CORA page; Colorado Secretary of State CORA information.
  • SB22-156, "Medicaid Prior Authorization And Recovery Of Payment," limits clawback periods and constrains prior authorization for outpatient mental health care. Anthem's outpatient behavioral health prior authorization requirement ended in August 2022 with SB22-156. Source: SB22-156 bill page. Read about prior authorization.

COMBINE's position

  • Give the State Auditor power to audit RAEs. The LAC should advance a bill extending OSA audit authority to managed care entities. That bill should be separate from community mental health centers.
  • Enforce the contracts HCPF already has. Performance standards on call times, provider responsiveness and claims payment should be reported publicly and enforced.
  • Open the books. Deliverables on network adequacy, provider rosters and finances should be posted promptly. Rate-setting policy should not be hidden as a trade secret.
  • Limit clawbacks. Payers should recoup money only within a reasonable period, as at least 10 other states require.

What we've done

  • 2019 onward: Advocated for more oversight of the RAEs (legacy LAC page).
  • 2020: Helped develop the Medicaid RAE escalation form.
  • February 21, 2021: Sent HCPF oversight questions to the Joint Budget Committee on network adequacy, prior authorization, rates and credentialing. Read the questions (PDF).
  • May 2021: Asked legislators to regulate clawback periods. Read the Regulate Clawbacks 1-pager (Google Doc).
  • 2021, 2022 and 2023: Appealed to the LAC to expand the State Auditor's authority over RAEs.
  • 2022: Worked with sponsors Kolker, Amabile, Fenberg and Young on SB22-156. Anthem's outpatient prior authorization requirement ended in August 2022.
  • October 13, 2023: Asked the LAC to vote on an amended audit bill covering managed care entities only. Read the letter (PDF).

Last reviewed 2026-11-21